I recently finished the book Simplicity Parenting: Using the Extraordinary Power of Less to Raise Calmer, Happier, and More Secure Kids by Kim John Payne. I thought this was a great read. I would certainly recommend it to other parents. Of course, there are some suggestions in the book that I simply (haha) couldn’t see my family executing– like taking the TV out of our living room or removing, essentially, most of the books from my kids’ room. However, so many of the suggestions I agree with, and even those that I don’t, warrant taking a pause and thinking through what is right and best for my family, our environment, our habits.
The Simplicity Parenting website gives the following overview:
Simplicity Parenting based on the book by Kim John Payne offers a simple, orderly, and effective pathway to simplify four realms at home, which reduces stress on children and their parents, and allows room for connection, creativity, and relaxation.
These four realms for simplifying are:
- Environment: De-cluttering too much stuff at home.
- Rhythm: Increasing predictability by introducing rhythmic moments for connection and calm.
- Scheduling: Soothing violent schedules brings moments for Being into all the Doing.
- Unplugging: Reducing the influence of adult concerns, media and consumerism on children and families to increase resilience, social and emotional intelligence.
Parents who take steps along this pathway to simplify their homes and their schedules, to introduce more predictable rhythms and to filter out concerns which children are not yet able to cope with, find that their children:
• Are calmer and happier
• Do better socially and emotionally
• Are more focused at school
• Find it easier to comply with family rules
• Become less picky eatersThese parents also find that they themselves:
• Have a clearer picture of what they value as parents
• Are more united with each other in their parenting
• Have more time and energy for connection, relaxation, and fun”
At the start of his book, Payne asks us the question: Why simplify at all?
Well, he holds that kids today in our cultural context are experiencing attention issues, anxiety, and depression at higher rates because of the overwhelm in their environments. At the start of his career, he counseled children affected by warzones and violent childhood trama (children who essentially were suffering from PTSD) and later in his career was finding similar symptoms in children who came from upper-middle-class families who were not growing up in war-torn regions of the globe. In treating the kids from both contexts, he found that going through a detailed “simplifying of their world” proved very effective and reduced or prevented the need for prescription medications.
Some thought-provoking quotes for me were:
“We are building our daily lives, and our families, on the four pilars of too much: too much stuff, too many choices, too much information, and too much speed. With this level of busyness, distractions, time pressure, and clutter (physical and mental), children are robbed of the time and ease they need to explore their worlds and their emerging selves.”
“Our society– with its pressure of ‘too much’– is waging an undeclared war on childhood.”
“Children need experiences, not entertainment, in play. The more kids can do, see, feel, and experience for themselves in play, the more connected they will feel to the world, and the less overwhelmed. We live in an information age, where kindergarten-age children know all about the tropical rainforest. Yet have they thoroughly mucked about in their own yards and neighborhoods?”
I think about this so much at this preschool stage (especially the third quote). I feel like my kids have too much. TOO MUCH STUFF. Do my kids really need ALL THE TOYS? And I certainly prefer when their toys don’t DO any of the playing FOR them. I am that mom who ALWAYS takes out the batteries and/or keeps the toy turned off. The grandparents consistently make jokes about it but they know after I take the toy home it WILL NOT have any noises or lights anymore. For my sanity, for the kids’, and for the dogs’. Those toys have no “staying power” at our house. In his simplifying the environment chapter, Payne doesn’t list specifically what toys to have or which toys to get rid of, but he does provide this guide for parents in the simplifying process.
Avoid:
- Toys that are conceptually “fixed” toys (toys based on movie characters, etc.
- Toys that “do too much” and break too easily
- Very high-stimulation toys
- Annoying or offensive toys
- Toys you are pressured to buy
- Toys that inspire corrosive play (violent video games, etc.)
- Toy multiples (sorry, no need for 100 beanie babies)
On these points, I could not agree more.
Thought-provoking quotes continued:
“Little ones ‘graze’ on our emotions. They feed on the tone we set, the emotional climate we create.”
When I, myself, am overwhelmed, or when I am frustrated, or when I am yelling (read: fed-up and mad), I am certain it affects my kids. How could it not? I will continue to keep at the forefront of my mind that my emotions are absorbed by and then mirrored back to me in my children. It becomes cyclical, but I, as the adult, have the conscious ability to break that cycle.
Thought-provoking quotes cont.:
“Part of an acorn’s telos, or destiny, is to become an oak. An acorn carries its telos within, from the beginning. Beyond our genetic gifts to them, beyond what they absord from us and their environment, children seem to arrive with something of their very own, a telos, or intrinsic nature.”
Having two boys only 18 months apart who are both biologically ours being raised in the same home environment, I have begun to think about this almost on a daily basis. Two kids who have so much in common, could not be more different. They are each CLEARLY their own acorn, with their own telos– or rather they might even be two entirely different seeds that will certainly flower into their own species of tree one day. I have to remember that my goal is not to make them into my tree or even into the same tree, but rather to guide them into growing into their own. This is WAY easier said than done. Every day I try– both to make them my tree and to help them become their own.
Thought-provoking quotes cont.:
“But a half hour or an hour of quiet, restful solitary time during the day is restorative at any age, and a habit worth cultivating.”
100% agree. This used to be 100% true in our house. I want this to ALWAYS be true in our house. My only question is… HOW DO YOU MAKE THE KIDS RECOGNIZE IT’S A HABIT WORTH CULTIVATING? Currently, my kiddos are more interested in playing “jump in the leaves” in their room during afternoon nap/rest time than being quiet (or heaven forbid *** sleeping*** during their half-hour or hour of quiet).
Thought-provoking quotes cont.:
“Meaning hides in repetition: We do this every day or every week because it matters. We are connected by this thing we do together. We matter to one another. In the tapestry of childhood, what stands out is not the splashy, blow-out trip to Disneyland but the common threads that run throughout and repeat: the family dinners, nature walks, reading together at bedtime… Saturday pancakes.”
I know we are enjoying this part of the preschool years. Repetition is fun. Family ritual is fun. Daily-ness is fun. Common threads are simple– but not always easy (see our nightly– often failed– attempts to get everyone to sit and eat at the dinner table. Although, every now and then there is that gem of a night where the stars align and it’s… awesome!). I wonder when the joy of repetition and simple togetherness will change. I do not welcome its demise.
However, the good news is that as I spend time with my 90+-year-old grandmother, it seems that this valuation of repetition as connection seems to come back around again if we are lucky enough to live that long, or wise enough to not forget it.
So, maybe Saturday pancakes and nature walks will always be the key to connection.
Thought-provoking quotes cont.:
“After all, it’s not just what you make of your time, it’s whether you have the time to make it your own.”
Well, for me at least, doesn’t it all just boil down to this one sentence. Time is all we have. We can’t save it. We can’t make more of it. If I want to teach my kids anything about time, it’s that they should make it their own.
In the last chapters of his book, Payne discusses the vital need for parents to function as a secure home-base for their kids as they grow, rather than the “helicopter” parent with which we are so familiar. He goes on to give advice regarding how to achieve this mindset given that parents often have their own anxieties and needs for their kids to become something, succeed at something, achieve something. His last suggestion, which I’ll quote below, is a habit I would live to cultivate in myself before coming obsessively involved in the trajectory of my kids’ lives:
“My last suggestions for backing off from overinvolvement is a simple one. I’ve seen it make a profound difference, however, in some parents’ attitudes, and the emotional climate of their parenting. It is a meditation, a mental exercise for the end of the day that will take just a minute or two. Before falling into sleep, remember the ordinary moments of the day, the moments with your children that mean something to you. This simple exercise is like a spritual corrective lense. In your vision of your kids it helps restore the prominance of ‘who are they’ over ‘what they need to do’ or ‘what they need to work on’.”
I want my kids to have a childhood full of the dailiness of simply being a kid so that they can grow into who they themselves can be. I want to cultivate and remember who they are, their telos. Payne encourages visualization as a key habit in simplicity parenting and this seems like a simple and great place to start.
I don’t know what this simple, dailiness of being a kid will look like as my boys get older and we have to consider more often balancing their schedule and all the activities that may infiltrate our days.
BUT… I can say, at this pre-school stage, it will mean fewer toys, less TV (our kids don’t interact with other screens), more focused family time, continued family dinners, and more unstructured outside time.
Today we basically spent the entire afternoon outside in the front and backyards and then cooked dinner over a backyard fire. It was a great day and the boys fell asleep (relatively) simply after a few bedtime books and creative stories.
However… Winter is coming… and Christmas is on the horizon. Time to cull some more toys. It should be simple, right?